Many of the negative reviews I saw were just because people didn't get good cards. If you plan on getting this, you have to know it comes with only 8 random packs, so there is a chance you won't get great pulls, that's how it goes with these things. Whether or not you get good pulls, you can't deny the value here. The material and quality of the box itself is very good for holding cards and the dividers are very helpful for organizing your cards. The poison, burn, and GX counter is a nice acrylic plastic, and the sleeves are good looking too. It's also nice to get the dice it comes with for damage counters and and as a substitution for a coin to flip. My favorite part of the box is the pack of energy's it comes wit because I always need energy for my decks and it can be annoying to buy theme decks for most of my energy. Overall the quality of this box and it's materials are very nice, and great for beginners getting into the game.